In the comments here, I asked blog friend Brian to tell me more about his home church. He sent me such a lovely, thoughtful email about the whole thing, about his spiritual process, that I asked him if I could please post it here. During the process of writing about church, I’ve been somewhat surprised at how many emails I’ve received from readers who don’t comment but who said to me, “I feel that way too.” “I feel alienated.” “I feel burned.” “I don’t know what to do.”
The church at large has a problem. It’s hurting its own people, not to mention the wrong message that sends to would-be or don’t-wanna-be Christians about what being a Christian actually IS.
So I share Brian’s email with those people too. It gives me hope. Maybe it will do the same for someone else. It teared me up with hope, actually, that maybe, just maybe, church can do what Jesus wanted it to do all along.
Thanks, Brian.
Here’s his email:
Tracey,
When I read things like your recent blog post it makes me sad. I cry because God wants so much more from his Church and some people just get in the way. We Christians have become a dysfunctional family, and who wants to be part of a dysfunctional family? Just drive down any street in this country and you’ll see church buildings on every corner and the only thing that divides them are rules or beliefs that man has put in place: we use electric guitars – well we don’t, we worship on Sunday – well we worship on Saturday, we take communion each week – well, we don’t… it goes on and on.
I’m going to make a very long story short.
I have been part of the institutional church all my life. I was baptized as a baby in the Catholic Church and again when I was seventeen and part of a non-denominational Christian Church. As it stands I believe that Jesus is the son of God, died on the cross, was buried, and raised to life three days later. I believe that the bible is the Word of God and he left it to tell us his story and if we want to know him we need to read his story. I believe that his Spirit dwells among us today teaching, guiding, and inspiring us. Beyond this I take things as they come and trust that the Lord knows better than I do.
About four years ago I started to really look at the church I was attending and how they were spending their time and resources. I began by reading and studying the four Gospels and the book of Acts to see what Jesus and his early followers were doing with everything they were given. The church we were attending had recently adopted the “seeker friendly” model that many mega-churches had adopted. Each week I started to see Jesus getting pushed to the side in favor of feel good sermons, stories, and events. Sermons became more like Dr. Phil or Oprah shows. Programs were started and forgotten. If there was a new person on Sunday morning I’d never know it because they’d be one of the thousand mixing in with the crowd. We built a coffee shop in the church and charged money for coffees and snacks under the guise of relationship building. Our monthly budget was well into the seven figures. If I drove by the church building during the week I noticed it was typically empty. The parking spaces that were filled were usually by the thirty plus staff members that worked there. All of this and our church was dying.
This pained me but I kept it to myself.
At this same time I was an adult leader with the High School students. On a mission trip to Mexico I ended up driving a supply van down that I was in charge of all week. One of the other adult leaders rode with me during the time we were in Mexico. Our discussions led to my feelings about the church and how Jesus was being left behind. She understood and felt the same way. She told me I should read a book – “Blue Like Jazz” by Donald Miller. I’d never heard of it. Donald Miller was from Portland which made it kind of cool. Upon my return to Portland I picked up a copy and devoured it. Where had this guy been all this time? He blew my mind. I’d never read anything like this by a Christian author. He nailed it for me and gave me the courage to stand up and start asking questions and to seek Jesus in our midst.
After Mexico and Blue Like Jazz my conversations with people changed and I found out I wasn’t alone. For the next three years I researched, talked, conversed, prayed, read, and really searched for Jesus. I got off my butt and started working with the homeless ministry downtown and even became a mentor to the guys in the program.
This journey brought us to some ugly places. We saw things in the church we didn’t like and things people did we thought made Jesus look bad. I know you’ve experience this also. In this journey we switched churches a few times and met a lot of different people. There was good and there was bad. We kept on the journey never giving up faith that God loved us and knew what was best for us. I get the impression this is where you and your husband are these days. Searching.
This year we started our son in a TaeKwonDo class to help build his confidence and to gain a little discipline. After a few weeks we learned that the Master’s who ran the Dojang were believers. They are awesome people. We learned that the Dojang was part of their ministry and that they also had a home church group that they were part of. They use the Dojang to be part of the community and to meet people and to be a light in a dark place. They are bold about their faith and they pull no punches (pun intended).
About the same time this happened my wife ran into an old college friend at the church we were attending on Sundays. She told my wife about the home church ministry that they were part of. My wife was intrigued. They run an organization that helps people in need fix their homes. It’s kind of like Habitat for Humanity but instead of building a whole house they fix what is already there. Through this organization they share Jesus and his love. Then on Sunday nights they meet in different homes and worship, commune, and celebrate life. We decided to get together with them for dinner to catch up on life and to hear more about their ministry.
At this dinner we got to share our story and our journey of the last couple years with them. They smiled and nodded. They knew. They had been there too. The husband recommended a book called “Pagan Christianity” by Frank Viola and George Barna. I picked up the book and read it. It confirmed many of the things that I had seen over the years that I didn’t think were parts of the church that God had written into his plan and some of the shortcomings of the institutional church. Side note in case you read it: some of the book is a little silly and the authors take it to the extreme in a few cases, but the authors are home church advocates and are trying to make their point that it is a better way to do church.
We are now part of our friend’s home church group. I’m also volunteering time with his non-profit organization. Four weeks ago I was on the roof, in the pouring rain, of a man who broke his back on the job and had a leaky roof. Through the amazing donations by local businesses and the volunteer time of a general contractor we totally replaced this family’s roof. No cost to them, no strings attached. We did it because we love Jesus and that is what he would have done. Tonight me and another guy are having coffee at the family’s house under their new roof.
When we meet on Sunday nights at someone’s house we sit together as fellow believers in Christ. We share a meal and sit and talk about life. We share scripture and what Jesus is doing in our lives. We tell our stories. We pray and meditate. Sometimes we will sing a song or two, sometimes we don’t. We laugh together and cry together. It is a family. It is Church how, in my humble opinion, God intended. The group is diverse, very diverse. We have old people and young, alcoholics & drug addicts, married, divorced, single, the fat and the thin, the employed and unemployed.
As I read the book of Acts I see the Church of that day meeting in homes, gathering in the community, supporting each other, loving each other, correcting each other, and living their lives in a way that glorifies the risen Christ. This is what we strive for. We are not perfect, we do not have all the answers, but we try and I think God will bless us for that.
For now we are putting our faith in God that he has us in the right place. We are at peace and really enjoying this new experience. People think we’re crazy and that’s okay, maybe we are.
Fantastic email… Ironically, to the “institutionalism” of the Catholic church (both small and big “C”, catholic) by Constantine, this is how “church” was done.
That said, there ARE many, many institutional churches of all faiths that haven’t lost focus of what a church should be, and I’m sure you and Brian would agree with me. These churches can provide more services than a “home” church for both members and non-members through pooling of resources, not the least of these is a full time pastor. We could not build a Habitat For Humanity house every year without both the money and the human resources that an organized church or churches can. You can’t bring high schoolers to Christ when you don’t have at least some other high school youth that they can relate to.
The classic analogy is to compare churches in America with businesses in America. We have big corporations, medium size businesses and small businesses. All are important to the economy and all have their advantages and disadvantages. I’m just glad we live in a country that allows diversity in both areas.
I love the fact that Brian has introduced a new potential avenue for your and MB’s faith. Again, the MOST important thing that I am praying for, is that y’all find the RIGHT spiritual home.
All the big churchyness and disconnection and nobody knowing each other is exactly why I feel at home in a really small church.
Our congregation is about 90 people, about 70 on a normal Sunday, and I love that. We all meet together at the building on Sundays, morning and evening, and then we split up and meet in homes for midweek Bible studies. We really are like a big family.
And the people at the congregation who I was worried wouldn’t accept me once they found out all my crazy? I was wrong. I love being wrong about people in a good way. Our last two congregations have been the least judgmental Christians I’ve ever been with.
That’s a great testimony. Gives me hope, too. Thanks to Brian for writing it all out.
Tracey, I have kept quiet through all these posts about your visits to church. I dreaded reading each new post, only because I dreaded how things might end.
THANK GOD for Brian reaching out to you in an email and your sharing it with us. In the last year I read Blue Like Jazz, and literally just finished Pagan Christianity this week. Both rattled and shook me.
It’s hard to think about walking away from all we know (the institutions we call church) and look for something new (or is it old?) In all honesty, except for a few visits here and there I haven’t attended church for 15 years. I am not where I want to be…….but I have been living my faith in front of my neighbors and coworkers as best I can, and seeing amazing things happen. I hope and pray you can also find a place of giving and receiving.
That was awesome, Brian.
CV — Hey, so nice to see you.
/I am not where I want to be ….. but I have been living my faith in front of my neighbors and coworkers as best I can, and seeing amazing things happen./
That really touches me. Thanks, CV.
Thank you for sharing your thoughts on “organic” church. Thought you might be interested to know that Barna/Viola’s “Pagan Christianity” wasn’t a stand-alone book. The sequel is called “Reimagining Church”, it’s the constructive part of the discussion. He also has a new book that’s the practical follow-up to both books. It’s called “Finding Organic Church.” Viola’s article “Why I Love the Church” explains the motivation behind all three books. http://frankviola.wordpress.com/2009/08/18/why-i-love-the-church-in-praise-of-gods-eternal-purpose/
Jill — Thanks for that link.
Also it cannot be overstated how awesome Brian is, just in general.
All I can say, Tracey, is that church experience has been a very interesting journey for us. Our faith has never waivered, but our view of how we need to live our faith with God’s people has. Church was very stressful for us for a few years. There was a lot of hurt and some anger. That, we knew, wasn’t good.
At times Brian and I were in different places of our journey. He would struggle at one place while I would stay looking forward. Then the roles reversed. Now, we’re at a place of peace – being with God’s people is just like being at home. We’ve also struggled with taking the kids through all of this and how they might come out in the end. I think they’re at a good place too.
I understand why people are disillusioned with the church and with Christians. There is hope out there. I wish I would have known years ago what I know now. But, I’m glad I went through the journey. And, I know that the journey is not over.
I love Brian and Kathi. Bless them both.