a burning harry potter question

DO NOT CLICK ON THE LINK HERE IF YOU HAVEN’T READ THE LAST BOOK YET!

OKAY??

Okay. Is it really true that NO ONE has input about the question I asked in the last paragraph of my post here?

Someone just tell me. Something. Anything. I need an answer! Please, smartypants-es!

7 Replies to “a burning harry potter question”

  1. Yeah, that’s what I thought — in the middle of the night. Why is it a child, I wonder? Maybe I’m asking too many questions. I was completely freaked out by the description, so I keep thinking about it.

  2. It’s very similar to the description of V-mort in GoF, before his re-embodiment. See the graveyard scene.

    Because he had to re-grow? I don’t know- sometimes her symbolism misses the mark. And sometimes she overdoes it, like with the names. I howled (no pun intended) at NF’s remark about Lupin. But I thought they were a lot of fun, at the same time. Old Classics major.

    I can’t be too hard on the last book- she did, after all, have to make up this whole world and figure out its magical rules and then conform events to their complexity. I think the whole thing kind of got away from her, in a way, in spite of all the pre-planning she did.

  3. Yeah, I enjoyed the book, Sal. I really did. I was just already going different ways in my own head. Which maybe isn’t fair to her. But there it is.

  4. I was going to agree with your Theory, Tracey, but since Sal already has, I guess there is no need for me to pile on. I too would have liked some kind of explanation for that, though.

    I loved the last book…I think just because I had made my mind up to love it. I agree it wasn’t the best of the seven. And despite that fact that it got away from her a bit, when taken as a whole, I think the series was remarkable. As I said before, I love her flawed characters. For a completely fantastical world with magical powers, her characters are amazingly human and real.

  5. I haven’t read the book yet…my husband refuses to buy it till it reaches $5…I may never have an answer to your question!!!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *