8 Replies to “new american idol judge?”

  1. I’m sure everyone has been awaiting my response to this horrible news. I’ll give you a preview: it includes the words “Yeah, and it’s NOT ME! What the–?”

  2. I actually would HATE to see Poorla go. I love her insanity! I don’t want someone more coherent. And four judges will just slow the whole thing down. Simon doesn’t get enough chance to talk as it is. Now if he’s last, forget about it. She’s clearly Poorla’s replacement; they just didn’t want to do it all at once. Phase her in, phase poor Poorla out. I think it sucks. There’s a certain bizarre chemistry between the three judges that will now be totally skewed.

  3. Agreed. I’d rather that they phase out NOBODY, but if anybody, then Randy, who is not very good. And poor Paula – she knows. She sees it. She was on the infotainment show pretty much the same day worrying aloud about things.

  4. Really? Oh, poor Poorla. I don’t want her to go!! And yeah, I agree with you about Randy. HE could go, as far as I’m concerned. He did his thang, dawg, but I’m not really feelin’ it. What chemistry there is — to modify what I said before — is more between Simon and Paula.

  5. In addition to the infotainment shows ‘Fly mentioned, Poorla is practically a weekly feature on “The Soup” when AI is going (that’s how I get all my reality show updates, pain-free–T, you could be one of their hilarious writers, hands down!). What would they do without her? This will cause a major ripple in the industry.

    Sarahk would be too much woman for Simon to handle IMHO. That’s probably not nice to say, but it’s most likely true.

  6. Kate P – /This will cause a major ripple in the industry./

    Hahahahaha! I’m laughing just picturing another strike because Poorla gets ousted at American Idol!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *