From the weekend:
~ Before our matinee of “V is for Vendetta” started Saturday, I ducked into the restroom. I was alone until she slumped in. I watched her in the mirror. She was solid, burly, decked out in an oversized t-shirt, matching oversized pants. Her feet didn’t step but shuffled across the tile. Head hung firmly down in a “don’t look at me” way. She clutched something in the crook of her elbow. What was it? The extra fabric of her shirt almost obscured it, but right before she disappeared into her stall, I caught a glimpse of what it was: an extra large tub of popcorn.
She brought her tub of popcorn into the restroom.
I was stunned. I thought maybe she’d ask me to watch it or hold it or something.
Nope. That enormous tub went right into the stall with her. I just stood there, transfixed, water continuing to pour over my now impossibly clean hands. I must have seemed OCD, but I just had to watch.
I could see her feet, of course, under the door of the stall. But where was the tub? Oh, look. There it is.
On the floor between her feet.
The tub was in the bathroom. In the stall. On the floor between her feet.
And right before I sprinted for the door, I saw her grabbing a big handful while stray white puffs fell to the floor around her feet.
~ Oh, and “V for Vendetta”? Ugh. Puhleaze. A movie we chose because there were no choices. Ah, sometimes that happens. You know, the whole “comic book” movie genre eludes me, really. Well, I liked Spiderman well enough, forcing myself to overlook that he is, after all, a SPIDER man. But I guess I lack the imagination or the testosterone or the whole “wow, I WISH I was 9 again” thing that one needs to really be swept away by it all. And THIS movie?? AAGGHH. I could NOT get past the fact that Hugo Weaving wore that preposterous Guy Fawkes mask the entire freakin’ time! Can a person really — enjoyably — look at this simpering thing for 2 hours?? It makes me want to kill people:
I confess I spent the larger part of the movie quietly egging on ANY character in ANY scene with V: “C’mon. Rip it off. C’MON! Pleeeeaaze …… DAMmit! I hate you! You know what? Now he’s gonna kill you and then you’ll be sorry because that pasty, RETARDED face is the last thing on this earth you’re gonna see!” Of course, underneath the smiling plastic, he’s apparently some horribly charred goblin, but I would have welcomed the chance just to look at FLESH, no matter what shape it was in. So when you think about it, he’s really just a big ol’ scab, a black, plastic, sadistic SCAB. Luckily Weaving is blessed with a rich baritone voice, providing the only expression he could even use in the role. It’s frustrating, because you know there’s a human being under there and yet, you don’t identify with him as anything remotely human. And yeah, yeah, supposedly, the movie makes you think about STUFF like: Was V a hero? Or a terrorist? Or some great tragic figure? Who CARES?? He was basically a freak in a freaky mask. But, really, it does make you think about other stuff too, like: Was that actually Hugo Weaving in the whole V getup? OR did he just do the voice and some other actor wore the mask, like the whole Darth Vader dealio from “Star Wars”? THAT’S what the movie really makes you think about, peeps. Blech.
~ Later that same day — I guess to punish myself for the movie — I bought some unsweetened chocolate soy milk. WHA??? Please. It was SO upsetting. Let’s not talk about it anymore.
~ Sunday afternoon, I bought some red and orange and fuschia ranunculus from the farmers’ market down the street. At home, I fussed over their clashing hues until they formed a fiery cluster that perfectly matched my unsweetened chocolate soy milk mood. My Beloved, though, saved the day by renting Pride and Prejudice with Keira Knightley. I’d been dragging my feet about seeing it because I’m SUCH a fan of the Colin Firth/Jennifer Ehle version, but it IS Pride and Prejudice, for Pete’s sake, and guaranteed to squeeze the sickly, unsweetened soy out of ANYONE!!
So, some random thoughts:
~ Donald Sutherland, his odd, aging face settling into a craggy warmth, is just wonderful as Mr. Bennet, always one of my favorite characters. His very presence is wry and soothing and a perfect counterpoint to the incessant flutter of his wife and younger daughters. Plus, he gets to utter lines like these: “Your mother will never see you again if you don’t marry Mr. Collins and I will never see you again if you DO.” Hahaha.
~ Gah, the actor who plays Mr. Collins — he’s just a hilarious little hobbit! He kills me with his wee-ness and obsequiousness, his silly intensity. I swear he speaks THE funniest line in the movie while at dinner at the Bennets’ humble home. The camera zooms in a tight close-up to a bowl of heaping potatoes, then we see Mr. Collins, struggling for something good to say. He says this: “What a superbly featured room and what …… excellent boiled potatoes. Many years since I’ve had such an exemplary vegetable.” The actor pauses for the merest second there, before the word “excellent.” I’ve now watched that moment over and over and it becomes more hilarious to me each time!
~ Keira Knightley deserved that Oscar nomination. She surprised me, really. Her Lizzie is lively and witty and stubborn, but she captures that certain lightness that Lizzie must have. She was luminous.
~ Yeah, yeah. Judi Dench as Lady Catherine. She’s great. Isn’t that a given with her?
~ Oooh. The scene near the end of the movie where Lizzie tells Mr. Bennet that she really LOVES Mr. Darcy. Now THAT is the tear-jerking scene of the entire movie! Not seeing Lizzie and Darcy end up together, but seeing father and daughter in their unabashed, bittersweet adoration of each other. Donald Sutherland is genius in that scene. I bawled like a baby.
~ And now, to my gripe: Matthew Macfadyen as Mr. Darcy. I’m sorry. He has the face of a over-scrubbed tuber, bumpen, lumpen and starchy. It does not woo or inspire or seduce, but rather begs to be bathed in butter and dolloped with sour cream. He’s a bowl of “excellent boiled potatoes” with a pleasant speaking voice. His eyes are rabbity, impassive. Close-ups of his face left me unmoved — and he’s Darcy, for God’s sake! That’s not the reaction a girl should be having. Oh, well, there IS the moment at the end of the movie where he comes a’stridin’ across the dewy morning field, coat tails rippling in the breeze, face in blessed shadow, and you momentarily feel something, but then suddenly the light comes up on that face and you hold your breath and ….. it’s just a dish of Darcy Au Gratin. So bottom line, he’s fine, I guess, if you like your Mr. Darcy tuber-faced and rabbit-eyed and incapable of making you swoon.
Here. I’ll just offer you a visual comparison. This will explain EVERYTHING:
Side Dish:
Main Dish:
AGAIN, THAT’S:
Side Dish:
Main Dish:
We all clear??
(Oh, but I’ve still watched it 2 times since we rented it. AND I’ve rewound the strolling through the dew scene more than a few times, mentally pasting Colin Firth’s face over The Tuber’s.)
I mean, it IS Pride and Prejudice after all!
Well, I am a comic-book movie fan. I don’t want to analyze myself over it, but I’m sure it has something to do with not wanting to let go of certain aspects of my childhood. That said, I’m not sure that V for Vendetta was the best adaptation. I haven’t seen it yet; not sure if I’m going to. Teflon said some good things about it on Molten Thought, but I’m still not sure.
When I first read the series, a youngun’, I liked it. It was an indictment against all that “facism” that exists in your teenage mind — as if to say, “Yeah man, we’re going to rise up against all those facists who dare tell us what to do.” But that was sad youthful angst and it doesn’t translate well into my adult world. I used to have fond memories of “V for Vendetta” until this movie came along and made me remember who silly all that angst was.
Oh well.
Glad you liked P&P. I picked up “History of Violence” and am looking forward to watching it, I mean, really, really looking forward to it.
Darcys in order of Darciness:
1) Lawrence Olivier (the movie)
2) David Rintoul (1980 BBC mini)
3) Colin Firth (1995 BBC mini)
4) Matthew MacFadyen (2005 re-make)
Elizabeths in order of Lizzieness:
1)Keira Knightley (2005 re-make)
2) Elizabeth Garvie (1980 mini)
3) Jennifer Ehle (1995 mini)
4) Greer Garson (the movie)
Adding up our scores, we get:
1980 BBC: 4 pts
The Movie and 2005 re-make: 5 pts each
1995 BBC mini: 6 pts
The 1980 BBC also features Judy Parfitt as Lady deBurgh and a fat, oozing, unctous Mr. Collins. Remember “I, Claudius”? The guy who played Nero?
That actor. Plus, there’s NO SNOGGING.
Netflix it or get it though Inter-library loan or something. It is Good.
I am so upset about the chocolate soy milk detail. It will take me some time to recover.
And fuggedaboutit with the most recent Pride and Prejudice. Colin Firth? YUM!!! Tuber lumpen starchy boy-band Renaissance-Fair-curly-locked Matthew Macfadyen? No.
Colin Firth is a MAN. Macfayden is more in the homunculit range.
Don’t MESS with my fantasies of Mr. Darcy, all you filmmakers!! Don’t be creative. Don’t try to re-think him, or re-interpret him. PLEASE!!!
Wrong Actor, above -sorry. Christopher Biggins was Nero, Collins was someone else, but still pretty lard-on-the-hoof.
But did you *LIKE* “V”?
“Darcy Au Gratin”… heh.
Yeah, we sat in the theater for “V”. I wasn’t as impressed as Tef was, but he’s read all the books. His take was kinda’ like, “Eh… coulda’ been better, but all in all not too shabby an adaptation.”
It speaks volumes that the creator of the “V” strip wouldn’t put his name anywhere near it, I think. ‘Course that’s more because of contracts and royalties than anything. It’s not the *worst* movie I’ve seen, but as far as a faithful adaptation, “Hellboy” it ain’t. And don’t even get me started on “Sin City”. The movie was too bloody and, um, *gross* for me personally, but the creator was on set every stinking day to make sure the end product was perfect.
And I can’t believe I know this. Any of it. That’s what I get for marrying a comicon.
And a closing thought: Colin Firth as Darcy diving into the lake in his white shirt and breeches… Mmm… yeah… Have a good, *GOOD* day.
You’re opening the proverbial can of worms, WG. I am a HUGE!!! Sin City fan. Both of the orignal series, Frank Miller in general and of almost all of Robert Rodriguez’s work. So, I was happy with it, but I also fully understand why someone wouldn’t be.
And, for faithful adaptations, I don’t think anyone has topped the original Superman. And that’s primarily because there have been so many adaptations of the Superman canon, that anything reasonably close is good enough. As long as you keep the basic character in line with the “overgrown boyscout” you’re good to go.
Spiderman came close though.
Gotta disagree with you, Sal, on the Darcys.
Colin Firth is #1. 😉
I can’t comment on any of these versions of Pride and Prejudice, because I haven’t SEEN any of them. I HAVE however seen Bride and Prejudice, starring Aiswarya Rai and…um…some guy who looks like Bill Pullman a little. Ah! Martin Henderson. Never heard of him before.
It’s P&P, set in modern times. And in India. There’s singing and dancing, too. Worth watching at least once, I think.
And red, YES, The Soy Incident was horrifying.
I’m sure I was possessed or something. I’m better now.
And Colin Firth — YUMMEEEE! YESSSS!! He’s no potato, he’s no unsweetened soy milk, he’s a MAN, BAY-BEE!!
We love him and we know he loves us and that’s all there is to it.
What’s that? I sound silly?? TOO BAAADDDDD!!
I’m kinda glad not to see Hugo Weaving’s face in another role. His Elrond and Agent Smith combo really clashed for me. I couldn’t decide if Elrond was just a pretty Smith or if Smith was Elrond realizing his greatest fantasy.
Oh Tracey. I was ECSTASTIC when I saw your topics. I’ve been out of the blog world this week, and I missed you!
I was excited about V when I saw the trailer. Looked like my kind of movie – suspense with not too much action, not to gory, but not dull either. Was I wrong. Ugh. Disappointment to say the least.
P & P – Prior to the 2005 version, I had only seen the OLD version twice. So-so at best. Just too old for me. THEN, I saw the 2005 version. OH what sweet goodness it was. FANTASTIC. FANTASTIC movie. At first, I was like, huh? this is the “Darcy” I’ve heard so much about? Kinda plain, isn’t he? But watch as he begins to melt the more he gets to know Lizzie. It really begins to soften when there at his house, and especially when he laughs in Georgiana’s company. Oh, sweetness.
But THE scene. When he walks across the field. Oh how my heart swoons. And the whole “Mrs. Darcy” thing on the pond at the end. tears.
I have watched this movie TWICE this week (in two days actually) since buying it LAST week. 4 times I’ve seen it now in total. It’s my favorite version.
After seeing it in the theater, I saw the BBC version, which I enjoyed for the detail. I’ve just never been a Colin Firth fan. I know, I know, don’t hate me. I like him more now after seeing it, but still, not as much as the other Darcy.
To each his own I guess. But we can all agree, these are fabulous movies. Whichever Darcy you choose.